If you need to identify a snake, try the Snake Identification Facebook group.
For professional, respectful, and non-lethal snake removal and consultation services in your town, try Wildlife Removal USA.

Wednesday, October 3, 2012

Why are there no herbivorous snakes?

This article is part of a series highlighting new research in snake biology presented by herpetologists at the World Congress of Herpetology VII in Vancouver, British Columbia. If you want to learn more about the WCH, check out the June 2012 issue of Herpetological Review, or follow the Twitter hashtag #wch2012, with which I will tag all posts in this series. This article was inspired in part by the research of Beck Wehrle, who did his Master's work on the microbial communities of iguanas, and by Cyndi Carter.


Herbivory (eating plants or their parts) is widespread among vertebrates. There are many herbivorous mammals: think of cows, deer, and other ungulates, as well as lagomorphs (rabbits and their relatives), kangaroos, elephants, sloths, hyraxes, manatees, and even some primates, including many humans. Many birds are herbivorous, including notably the Hoatzin of the Amazon basin, which eats only leaves, but more broadly the many seed- and grain-eating birds such as sparrows, buntings, chickadees, and many other familiar species. Among reptiles, there are herbivorous lizards (including several Filipino monitors, such as Gray's and Panay Monitors, which eat fruit, and Marine Iguanas, which eat only seaweed), turtles (Green Sea Turtles and most tortoises), and even some crocodilians (Simone Brito and colleagues reported Broad-nosed Caimans eating fruit in 2002). Nearly all frogs are herbivorous as tadpoles (and some as adults), and some salamanders, the sirenids, eat algae. There are also many herbivorous fishes: the Pacu of South America, many koi and goldfishes, parrotfishes, and some cichlids and catfishes. Notably absent, then, are the snakes.

A python eats a deer while ignoring plants
There are over 3400 species of snakes, representing >10% of all tetrapods: more than any other group except mammals, birds, and frogs. So why are there no herbivorous species of snake?

At least part of the secret is that nearly all these herbivores (at least, those that eat leaves and parts of plants that have high cellulose content) have something in common: they don't actually digest their own food. You see, much of the energy in plants is stored in their cellulose, a polymer (chain-like molecule) of several hundred to over ten thousand glucose (a common, energy-rich sugar) molecules linked together by β(1,4) bonds. Animals cannot make cellulase enzymes to break the β bonds in cellulose and obtain the monosaccharide glucose, which they can metabolize for energy. Instead, sophisticated endosymbiotic microbes that live in their guts do it for them. The microbes and their herbivorous hosts are digestive symbionts, or indispensable partners. This poses a problem: how do newborn herbivorous organisms get their gut colonies in the first place? The answer: from older members of the same species, including their parents. The transfer is facilitated by processes like live birth, nursing, and coprophagy (eating others' poop), as well as more generally by plenty of social contact thorough pair bonding and parental care, most of which are generally not present in snakes. To be fair, about 15-20% of snakes give live birth, and some have limited parental care and are social at times. But generally speaking, opportunities for microbe transfer between snakes are few and far between. What's more, restrictions of functional morphology probably restrict snakes' ability to evolve herbivory. The kinetic skull with its highly specialized musculature and dentition for swallowing large prey would be extremely unsuitable for the mastication required to pre-digest most plant tissue. There also isn't very much space in a snake's body for the exceptionally long/convoluted gut that seems to be necessary to house the microbial fauna necessary for complete digestion of plant tissue.

Galápagos Marine Iguanas (Amblyrhynchus cristatus)
It's interesting to consider what natural history attributes a herbivorous snake might share with other herbivorous reptiles. Most herbivorous lizards are social, including the Green Iguana and the Marine Iguana. Additionally, herbivory seems to be especially common among lizards on islands, where animal prey  abundance is chronically or periodically low. Predation pressure might also be low on such islands, allowing would-be ectothermic herbivores to meet their energetic demands by eating plants, digestion of which requires prolonged basking to achieve high body temperatures  which could increase predation risk. Many plants reward their herbivores with tasty fruits or nectar in exchange for seed dispersal or pollination - lizards in the MediterraneanNew Zealand, and Mauritius are plant pollinators, and there are lots of examples of mammalian, avian, and invertebrate pollinators. Is it such a stretch to imagine a snake somewhere that enters into this kind of relationship with a flowering plant?

Bagheera
The recent discovery of herbivory in a species of jumping spider, named Bagheera kiplingi by a Jungle Book aficionado,  means that another predominantly carnivorous group contains at least one herbivorous member. These spiders eat Beltian bodies (little packets of fat and protein produced by Acacia trees to reward their ant mutualists/defenders), although they also eat insects. Some other spiders also feed on nectar and might be pollinators. Intriguingly, members of the genus Bagheera are also unusually social for spiders. No word yet on the composition of their digestive microflora, but other plant-tissue-eating arthropods, the termites, rely on similar endosymbioses to vertebrate herbivores.

Tentacled Snake (Erpeton tentaculatum)
Herbivory by a snake has actually kinda-sorta been reported in the peer-reviewed literature once or twice. As far back as 1875, when French naval physician and naturalist Albert Morice wrote the first detailed account of the fauna of Cochinchina, he remarked on how often algae and fragments of aquatic plants were found in the digestive system of the Tentacled Snake, Erpeton tentaculatum. Other authors have remarked on this as well, and according to Morice's account, the local people told him that they knew the snake consumed plants. Hubert Saint Girons, writing in 1972, suggested that in the course of hunting fish in a vegetation-rich freshwater environment, parts of plants might be uprooted and swallowed with the prey. More recent herpetologists have concluded that the presence of plant debris in the stomach contents of E. tentaculatum is, in fact, probably accidental. Furthermore, because there are no  morphological modifications to the dentition or digestive system of E. tentaculatum that would suggest a herbivorous diet, there is no reason to suspect that these plants are consumed on purpose. Nevertheless, the statement that Erpeton is a herbivorous snake has been propagated in several sources, although it is not really accurate.

The more compelling case comes from a study done on island Cottonmouths (Agkistrodon piscivorus) by Harvey Lillywhite and colleagues, published in the journal BioScience in 2008. During a study of pitviper scavenging in the intertidal zone conducted on Florida's Seahorse Key, Lillywhite observed Cottonmouth turds containing relatively large amounts of seaweed (up to 54 grams, or pretty much the entire turd). This seemed like a lot of material to be secondarily or accidentally ingested, and Lillywhite speculated that the Cottonmouths might be eating seaweed because it smelled like fish. Then he and his team went further: to test this idea, they presented Cottonmouths snakes in the laboratory with marine plant materials with and without fish present. The snakes thoroughly investigated the algae lacking fish scent for several minutes, with frequent tongue flicking, pushing, and probing, but they did not attempt to ingest it. When the presentation was repeated using plant materials rubbed with a dead fish or loosely enveloping a piece of fish, the snakes voluntarily swallowed the marine plants that had contacted fish, whether or not the fish was still present. Pics or it didn't happen? Here's the proof:

Figure from Lillywhite et al. 2008

I researched this topic a while ago and intended to make a post about it at some point. What reminded me was actually an experience I had while I was at the WCH: an interesting piece of evidence for a very strange kind of herbivory in a snake came to my attention. My good friend Cyndi Carter, a student of ecology at the University of Georgia, told me I had three chances to guess what she found in a Cottonmouth stomach, and that if I got it she would buy me a large ice cream. My first guess was a dead cat, which they have been known to eat. As a hint, she told me that she found it when she tried to inject the snake with formalin and couldn't get the needle in. After two more wrong guesses on my part (turtle, rock), she showed me this picture:


That's right, a pine cone. Can Cyndi, Joe Mendelson (whose snake it was), or I explain this? We cannot. Maybe it smelled like a fish.




ACKNOWLEDGMENTS


Thanks to Cyndi Carter for the picture of the pine cone, James Van Dyke for articulating what I meant to say about constraints of functional morphology at the end of the third paragraph, Joe Mendelson for clueing me in to the herbivorous frog Xenohyla truncata, and Patrick Prévost for his excellent article and  photograph of Erpeton tentaculatum, one of my favorite snakes.

REFERENCES

Brito, S. P., D. V. Andrade, and A. S. Abe. 2002. Do caimans eat fruit? Herpetological Natural History 9:95-96.

Cowen, R. 1989. Alimentary, My Dear Hoatzin: Ruminations on a Gutsy Bird. Science News 136:269-270.

Dunn, E. R. 1924. Siren, A herbivorous salamander? Science. 59:145.

Farlow, J. O. 1976. Speculations about the diet and foraging behavior of large carnivorous dinosaurs. American Midland Naturalist. 95:186-191.

Fleming, T. H. and K. R. Lips. 1991. Angiosperm endozoochory: were pterosaurs Cretaceous seed dispersers? American Naturalist. 138:1058-1065.

Lillywhite, H. B., C. M. Sheehy III, and F. Zaidan III. 2008. Pitviper scavenging at the intertidal zone: an evolutionary scenario for invasion of the sea. BioScience 58:947-955 <link>

Meehan CJ, Olson EJ, Reudink MW, Kyser TK, Curry RL (2009) Herbivory in a spider through exploitation of an ant–plant mutualism. Current Biology 19:R892-R893. 

Moll, D. and K. P. Jansen. 1995. Evidence for a role in seed dispersal by two tropical herbivorous turtles. Biotropica. 27:121-127. 

Morice, A. 1875. Sur les habitudes d'un remarquable serpent de la Cochinchine: I'Herpeton tentaculatum. Annales des Sciences Naturelles 6:128-129. 

Olesen, J. M. and A. Valido. 2003. Lizards as pollinators and seed dispersers: an island phenomenon. Trends in Ecology & Evolution 18:177-181. 

Pryor, G. S., D. P. German, and K. A. Bjorndal. 2006. Gastrointestinal fermentation in Greater Sirens (Siren lacertina). Journal of Herpetology 40:112-117. 

Sokol, O. M. 1967. Herbivory in lizards. Evolution. 21:192-194. 

Van Damme, R. 1999. Evolution of herbivory in lacertid lizards: effects of insularity and body size. Journal of Herpetology. 33:663-674. 

Walls, G. Y. 1981. Feeding Ecology of the Tuatara Sphenodon punctatus on Stephens Island, Cook Strait. New Zealand journal of ecology 4:89-97.


Creative Commons License

Life is Short, but Snakes are Long by Andrew M. Durso is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License.

19 comments:

Bill said...

Great post with some great sources! I have a minor nitpick, though. You refer to Bagheera kiplingi as herbivorous and this is technically not true. It actively practices herbivory but it also is known to eat insects like a normal spider and is thus omnivorous.

Andrew Durso said...

Thanks Bill, you're correct. I might expect any plant-eating snake also to be omnivorous - it's hard to escape those millions of years of strict ancestral carnivory.

David Steen said...

I'm going to go out on a limb and say a Cottonmouth would eat anything that smells like fish/amphibians, etc. So I'm going to say this is not evidence for herbivory, just incidental ingestion. Without going back to read the original BioScience article, that's the take-home message I'm getting. If that's the most compelling case for herbivory, then I think the quest should continue.

Andrew Durso said...

Dave, I agree. I think the current most accurate conclusion is that there are no herbivorous snakes. I doubt even those Cottonmouths can extract any nutrition from plant material.

Alan said...

Given that snakes are obviously capable of drinking easily, it is a bit surprising that there are no nectivorous snakes feeding from flowers - one would think that would be a fairly small step to make for an arboreal species. Or are there?

Andrew Durso said...

Good question and observation, Alan. To my knowledge there are not, but if anyone knows of any, let me know!

David Steen said...

Do geckos count?

Panju and Mallu said...

Once again, a very nice article.
But why not frugivory? Fruits are more energy rich than other plants parts (I think), and swallowing a ripe fruit would be not much different from swallowing a small mammal or an egg! I mean, the musculature or teeth wouldn't have to change much, would it?
Are endosymbiotic microbes necessary for digesting fruits?

Hari

Andrew Durso said...

That is a very good thought! In fact, when I first wrote a version of this article for a facetious herpetological journal that my friends and I created in college, I made an outlandish prediction that one day a species of frugivorous snake would evolve or be discovered, for the exact reasons (few morphological or physiological modifications necessary) you mention. If one day we are vindicated, perhaps it will be named for one of us!

emydoidea said...

I can think of one reason snakes might not be able to easily evolve frugivory. Plants with edible fruits commonly have poisonous seeds to prevent their animal dispersers from purposely targeting the seeds as food (apples and cherries come to mind). Mammals or birds that crack open the seeds will be poisoned, while those that swallow the seeds intact with the fruit will pass them unharmed. It seems that snakes, with their comparatively slow, powerful digestion, would break down the seeds and be poisoned. It would also presumably be difficult to evolve resistance to multiple toxins in order to eat a wide variety of fruit (frugivorous monitors appear to mostly eat Pandanus, of which at least some species have edible seeds).

Andrew Durso said...

It's a good point, especially that snake digestion might be too slow for them to serve as seed dispersers. There are some multi-toxin-resistant snakes out there, but as far as we know none are particularly resistant to plant toxins (not that many have looked). The species I study are resistant to bufadienolide toxins, which are produced by toads but also by fireflies and by some plants.

emydoidea said...

Offhand I can find plenty of references to granivorous rodents avoiding poisonous seeds, but nothing about any that safely eat them. Maybe common seed toxins (or the quantities of toxin involved) are difficult to evolve resistance to compared to animal toxins. However, I wonder if even a large meal of fruit would actually take very long for a snake to digest, given that it's probably easier to break down. It might make poisonous seed issue a moot point. Most importantly, though, enquiring minds want to know: can hognoses safely eat Scilla bulbs?

Andrew Durso said...

I don't know about Scilla (someone should try!), but presumably they could safely ingest the bufadienolides in plants such as Urginea and Kalanchoe, if they could digest their other parts.

A said...

Done¡¡ Discovered this site some days ago and finally I could read all the posts. The blog is AMAZING. For the newbies, Could it be possible a series of post on "Intro to Snakes" explaining basic anatomy, taxonomy,...?? Anyway THANKS for the blog

Andrew Durso said...

Thanks so much for the positive comments! That's a good idea. I've got a few more posts in the works currently, including one on fossil snakes (which will address the origins of the group as a whole) and others on cool natural history that are more similar to what's up here already. A basic taxonomy or anatomy post would definitely be possible.

Xaali O'Reilly said...

Great post!

I reckon give it a few million years (if we haven't destroyed the planet) and they'll be at least one herbivorous snake

Andrew Durso said...

I reckon you're right, Xaali, even if humans are gone by then.

Vishal Verma said...

is there any enzymatic activity in animal's brain that activates our choice to prefer herbivorous diet or eating plants, if it is there then it will be very easy to understand why there are no herbivorous snakes.

RADHE KUMAR said...

Are you looking for the one of the best and most popular indoor plant which is 'Snake plant' is also called as “Sansevieria Trifasciata” and it is also named as Viper’s Bowstring Hemp, or mother in Law’s tongue or Saint George’s Sword.

snake-plants-mother-in-law-tongue-plant benefits and plant care guide